Clinic Notes: Special Education and Autism Stats

According to some reports we are in the midst of an autism epidemic with one out of every 150 children diagnosed. At the same time the number of children diagnosed with learning disabilities or mental retardation is declining. Now we hear that for the first time in history the number of children in Special Education declined by 2.4%. (http://tinyurl.com/yuh59z) Furthermore, the number of children age 3-5 entering public education with speech/language impairments dropped 5%.
So what's happening? Are the speech/language impaired kids, which make up half of the kids with disabilities, now being diagnosed with autism and going into private autism schools where they can get more ABA? I'm confused

Clinic Notes: Thomas the Train, Bob the Builder, and ABA

There is some literature that suggests that children do not make eye contact because they perceive eye contact with another person as threatening. In fact some studies fine that if children with eye contact do look at faces they only see the mouth and nose. Interestingly, the face on Thomas the train and the construction equipment on Bob the Builder attract many children with autism. A recent study in Great Britain (http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/6241733.stm) used vehicles with human faces to try and teach children with autism to overcome their fear of looking at faces. In my clinic I have been using Thomas the Train and Bob the Builder videos to teach children with autism how to label emotions with some success and plan a controlled study in the near future.

Clinic Notes: ABA and the Neurosciences

Most ABA therapists have little background in the neurosciences. Unfortunately, this often results in a "one size fits all" approach to ABA. In our clinic some children with neurological impairment resulting in low muscle tone get fatigued very quickly doing Discrete Trial Training (DTT). With these children we slow down, have longer intervals between trials and give frequent breaks. I've seen ABA therapist push these kids to the point that they break down and profit little from ABA. Other kids with ADHD types of behavior may need shorter intervals between trials and less frequent breaks to keep them on tasks. In my few view, at least one course in basic neuroscience.

Clinic Notes: The Autism Genome Project

What is being hailed as the largest genome scan ever has come up with two genetic abnormalities in families with at least two member diagnosed with autism. The gene neurexin 1 located on chromosome 2, which is know to be associated with the neurotransmitter glutamate, is one suspect as is several locations on chromosome 11. As many as 30 other genes are also suspects in the disorder and are under investigation. Research in genetics is an important part of the puzzle and these are interesting findings. But I am still puzzled. When you read genetic studies somewhere in the write up autism is referred to as a highly inheritable disorder. However, the concordance rate for identical twins is only 60% and drops to 4-8% for fraternal twins and non-siblings. Without doubt something else is involved in the etiology of autism.
(See Nikhil Swaminathan. http://tinyurl.com/ynr6ey)

Clinic Notes: Autism Myths

The sign hanging in front of my clinic building says, "The Children's' Treatment Center." And in small letters under the name, "For Autism or other Childhood Developmental Disorders." I am located in an old historic part of town where buildings build in the late 1800's have been restored; surrounded by lawyers, CPA's, and upscale retail stores. I am always asked the question by people aroung me, "What is autism?" That is a difficult question to answer and difficult for people to understand. The movie "Rain man" is the only exposure most people have had to autism until recently when autism has been in the popular media.
Part of the problem in answering this question for the general public is the lack of consensus for those of us who work in the field. Simple questions such as "Is autism increasing in children," cannot be answered to everyone's satisfaction. We are not even close to answering the question, "What causes autism."
There are so many controversies that "experts" at the 2006 annual meeting of the American Association for the Advancement of Science tried to separate "fact" from myth. Unfortunately, the experts could only argue about the interpretation of the limited amount of data, often contradictory, that we do have.
(See Ped Med: Autism Myths Abound
By Lidia Wasowicz for UPI.)

Clinic Notes: The New Autism Numbers

In a recent study, CDC reports that 1 in every 150 school age children are affected by autism. When I started practicing 35 years ago the numbers were more like 1 in 10,000. The lower rates are reported in the South and the higher rates in North Eastern cities. Whether this difference is real or because more services are available and a diagnosis is more likely in the North Eastern cities than the South is not known. The authors of the study say that the rise in autism rates could be related to better surveillance procedures now than in the past. Personally, I don't think 1 child out of every 150 has any chronic disease, Including autism. (Diaper rash could be the exception.)
(See Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report Source reference: MMWR 2007, 56;SS-1;1-28.)

Clinic Notes: ABA, Music, and Autism

I see many children with autism in my clinic who are music savants. They have perfect pitch and can play a song on the keyboard after hearing it one time. The percentage of child with autism that have special music abilities is not know, but it is estimated that 10% of children with autism are savants.
In addition, many children with autism like music and we use it as a reinforcer in ABA programs. (Some kids with autism find music, and sounds in general aversive and cover their ears.) Neuroscientists tell us that infants are born with music preferences and even seem to enjoy music while still in the womb.
Some years back I had a 3 year-old girl come to my clinic with a diagnosis of autism. When I was taking her history her mother said she was not verbal, but she could sing. I then asked if she could follow directions. The mother said yes as long as she sang them. I then watched mother sing a direction and her daughter sang back her reply.
Tere is no music center in the brain. Pitch, loudness, and dimensions of music are in circuits of nerve cells, which are spread around in different parts of the brain. Why some children with autism have savant abilities is not even close to being understood.

Clinic Notes: ABA and the Rising Number of Children Diagnosed with Autism

In the January 31, 2007 Schafer Report (http://www.SARnet.org/), two separate articles dealt with the rising number of children diagnosed with autism. In California, 3385 new were added last year. The second article discussed the difficulty in determining whether or not the increase was real, and if it was, what was causing the increase.
Without doubt, I think there is an increase in the diagnosis and miss-diagnosis of autism. I see that almost everyday in referrals made to my clinic. But I also think there is something else going on. Autism does have a genetic link, but I'm not sure more people carrying the autism gene or genes are breeding and having more children with autism. I have no data to support that belief, but that is my belief. I think our attention needs to be directed towards the environment.
At any rate, it is getting very difficult for those of us in ABA to offer intense ABA for a child when we have so many children diagnosed with autism on our waiting list. Do I schedule one child for 10 hours of ABA a week? Or do I see ten children for one hour?

Clinic Notes: Risperdal, ABA, and Autism

A recent government study by the HHS' Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality found problems associated with off-label uses of Atypical Antipsychotic medications. Atypical Antipsychotic medications were developed to treat schizophrenia and bipolar disorders, but are now being prescribed for the elderly with dementia as well as children with autism. One atypical antipsychotic medication, Risperdal is approved for treatment of agitation and irritability in children ages 5-16 diagnosed with autism. Prescribing medications to children should be a last resort, only undertaken after all other therapies have been tried. But I can tell you that in many children with autism Risperdal is a necessary drug

Clinic Notes: Asperger's, ABA, and Crime

I see a number of children diagnosed with Asperger's Syndrome in my clinic. When they first present academic performance is the problem parents complain about the most followed by social problems. Children with Asperger's generally do well in math, spelling, and have trouble in science and social studies where they have to summarize information. Discrete Trial Training (DTT) and other ABA procedure are usually effective in managing the academic problems that Asperger's children have. The social problems associated with Asperger's are more difficult. We use a lot of social stories to teach social skills and how to behave in various situations and this works fairly well. But there is always a social situation that we did not anticipate that causes problems, especially for the adolescent. I wasn't surprised to see the news report this week where, allegedly, a teen with Asperger's stabbed a fellow student to death. The Asperger's defense has been used successfully in murder cases as well as other criminal charges, but I take no comfort in that. Seeing that no child with Asperger's commits a crime is a serious responsibility for ABA therapists.

Clinic Notes: ABA and Eye Contact Revisited

In a post last week I mentioned a study that found that children with autism perceived faces as threatening and that was the reason they did not make eye contact. The first ABA program in my ABA eBook is on eye contact. And I know from many years of clinical experience that a child with autism is not going to advance until they are making eye contact on command and are also making spontaneous eye contact.
A project in Great Britain is using cartoons of human faces on vehicles such as trains and cars to teach children with autism to make eye contact and understand human emotions. I have ordered their DVD and will evaluate this approach. In a future blog I will post the results

Clinic Notes: Mysteries and Autism

The best account that I have ever read of what it is it is like to have autism is a novel titled, The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Nighttime by Mark Haddon. A recent issue of the Schafer Report (Friday, January 12, 2007) describes a ten-year old child with autism who writes mysteries, which include people he knows in as various characters such as villain (the principal).
The mystery story has a long history in neurology. As I mention in the preface in my case history eBook, Little Bubba's Not Ready for Nashville, Yet, the most famous detective in fiction, Sherlock Holmes, was based on one of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s medical school professors at the Royal Infirmary in Edinburgh where he was a student in the late 1800s. Apparently, like Holmes, neurologist Joseph Bell mystified Doyle and his fellow students with his gift for clinical diagnosis. As I do research into the causes of autism and work with children with autism in my clinic and try to unravel the mystery of autism I often wonder what Holmes would do.

Clinic Notes: Eye Contact and Autism

A recent study at the University of Wisconsin suggests that children with autism do not make eye contact because they see faces as threatening. http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2005/03/050309151153.htm
Perhaps children with autism do see faces as threatening. I won't argue that. And I am familiar with the controversy about whether or not we should require that children with autism make eye contact. Many of the children with autism who come to my clinic, especially the young children, do not make eye contact on command or spontaneous eye contact. Of course, this results in social impairment, but it also results in impairment in observation learning or modeling and numerous developmental delays. The first ABA program in my eBook is on establishing eye contact. And the ABA program for eye contact is not first by accident. Thirty-five years of clinical experience has taught me that if eye contact is not established, the child with autism is not going to advance.

Clinic Notes: Ballet and Autism

A recent Schafer Autism Report had a story on a dance instructor in New York who was teaching a ballet class for girls with autism. Many children with autism have body orientation problems. For example, they will sit in front of the TV and not understand that other people cannot see the TV because of them. Or they will look at pictures in a book and think everyone in the room can see the pictures even though they are on no position to do so. One child with autism who comes to my clinic won an award at school. The principal asked her to come to the stage and stand beside him so he could present the award. Obligingly, she went to the stage and stood beside him, but facing away from the audience. Of course, everyone laughed and she got embarrassed. She thought she was doing what she was asked to do.
Spatial concepts and body orientation are difficult for a child with autism and I hope ballet helps the girls in the class. My qestion is since autism is four to five times more common in males why only a class for girls. I'm curious who decided the class would only be for girls. The teacher or parents of male children with autism

http://tinyurl.com/ylmc75

Clinic Notes: Preventing Autism Redux

In a previous post I described several studies, which found that intensive ABA in young children at risk for autism seemed to work. Of course, identifying children at risk for autism while they are young is a major hurdle. Some kind of early screening system, perhaps involving pediatricians and early well-baby exams, would have to be established. But there is a second hurdle and that is accepting the idea that intensive ABA changes the mis-wiring in the brain. Most everyone now accepts the idea that autism is a neurological disorder. But not everyone accepts the idea that ABA is rewiring faulty brain circuits.

Clinic Notes: Autism and the Christmas Holidays

I am reposting this for the holidays:
I have had many parents of children with autism or other neuropsychological disorders tell me that the Christmas holidays are an especially difficult time for them. Of course, any holiday can be difficult for any child with the changes in routine. But Christmas is usually the most difficult holiday for parents of children with autism or other neuropsychological disorders.
There are no sure-fire techniques to use with your child that will insure a "Martha Stewart Christmas." Families who have children with autism or other neuropsychological disorders have used the following 10 tips to make their Christmas better. And this year I'm adding a new suggestion to the list.
Several years ago Leigh Grannon and I did a study using pictures to increase social interactions in a child with autism. Children with autism are visual learners, and I have suggested to parents that they take pictures of what is going to happen at Christmas--the tree, the gifts, the relatives--and starting several weeks before Christmas show these pictures repeatedly to the child with autism. Tell a little story to the child while he/she is looking at the picture about how to behave, what's going to happen, and what the child can do if it is too much. Include your child in the pictures if possible. A picture of the child going to his room to escape the noise and confusion when he/she gets overloaded seems to help, too.
1. Try to keep your child in his or her usual routine as much as possible.
2. Sensory over stimulation—the lights, the sounds, the smells, the relatives touching your child--are the main culprits during the holidays. Eliminating or minimizing these culprits are your best bet.
3. Some families who have children with autism or other neuropsychological disorders wait until Christmas Eve to put up their tree and decorate.
4. Some families let their children with autism or other neuropsychological disorders do all of the decorating. Children with autism or other neuropsychological disorders may line up or stack decorations rather than decorate in the traditional way, but so what.
5. Rather than try to do the Christmas shopping with children with autism or other neuropsychological disorders in a crowded, noisy mall, many families shop by catalog or online and let the child point to or circle the toys he/she wants. Websites, such as www.stars4kidz, offer a variety of toys for children with autism or other neuropsychological disorders. Just type "autism toys" in your search engine.
6. Tactile toys are often a better choice for children with autism or other neuropsychological disorders. Toys that make sounds or involve too much stimulation or are too complex may not cause an aversive reaction in the child. As mentioned above there are web sites that sell toys designed for children with autism or other neuropsychological disorders. Try ordering some of these toys and then let your child select the ones to play with as they are unwrapped.
7. Talk to relatives before they come over about the best way to behave with children with autism or other neuropsychological disorders. Have them read my article, “What Horses Tell Us About Autism,” which is available for free on the second page of my website.
8. Generally, kids with autism or other neuropsychological disorders do better in the morning than in the late afternoon or evening when they are tired. It may be better to schedule Christmas events at these times.
9. The parents of children with autism or other neuropsychological disorders need to relax themselves. Often the child with autism picks up on the parents’ stress and that is enough to ruin Christmas.
10. And last but not least, realize that you are probably not going to have a perfect food, perfect decorations, and perfect gifts. Christmas with children with autism or other neuropsychological disorders may not be traditional, but it can still have real meaning. (Sometimes I wonder if children with autism or other neuropsychological disorders know that Christmas has become too commercial.)
I wish you and your child the happiest of holidays.
Gary Brown, Ph.D
Psychologist/HSP

Clinic Notes: Autism as a Neurological Disorder vs. Autistic Behavior

Presently we are analyzing data from over 2500 surveys from mothers of children diagnosed with autism and mothers of normally developing children. The survey, which can be found at http://www.ABA4Autism.com, has a variety of pre and post-natal questions. In the biographical portion of the survey we ask mothers to give us their child's diagnosis. We thought we would get several different diagnostic labels such as autism, PDD-NOS, or Asperger's. Instead we have so many diagnostic labels that we are not sure how to proceed. We have many comorbid diagnoses such as Down's syndrome and autism, Fragile X syndrome and autism, Autism Spectrum Disorder, with and without comorbid disorders, and countless more. Physicians or psychologist made all of these diagnoses. There are many problems in diagnosing autism and I certainly don't have the answer for all of the problems. But I think much of the confusion is caused by professionals who talk of atism as a neurological disorder and professionals, sometime the same professionals, who talk about autistic behaviors such as self-stim, OCD, sensory issues, etc. These "autistic behaviors" can be seen in a wide variety of neurological disorders. Before we can do definitive research in autism we need to be clear on what we are talking about when we make a diagnosis.

Clinic Notes: The Combating Autism Act

According to a recent note in the Schafer Report funding for investigating the role of environmental factors as a possible cause of autism has been removed in the House by Energy and Commerce Chair Joe Barton. The Senate has already voted 100 to 0 to fund special centers that would focus on the role of environmental factors as possible cause of autism. I don't know how this will all turn out in this lame duck congress. Last summer the Senate voted to exclude money that would look into vaccines containing thimerosal as a possible cause of autism. So both houses are trying to play to special interest and hogtie science. But science doesn't work that way. I have no idea whether thimerosal or environmental factors are involved in autism. We are now analyzing data from over 2500 surveys from mothers of children with autism and normally developing children and we will look at what we damn well want to. And the rest of the scientific community should do the same. Many in Congress have already demonstrated that they are cntrolled by special interest and are not concerned with finding a cure for autism. Science should find away to do the research without government funding.Schafer Autism Report Nov. 20, 2006

Clinic Notes: Mercury and Autism

In 1971, Iraq was given 90,000 metric tons of wheat seed by the United States. The seed was supposed to be planted by the Iraqis and had been treated with the fungicide methylmercury. Unfortunately, the Iraqis ground the seed and baked it into bread. Six thousand people were hospitalized with mercury poisoning and 450 died. Pregnant women gave birth to children with mental retardation, seizures, and other birth defects. The number of children, if any, who developed autism, is unknown. Without question mercury causes brain damage in children and adults. And like other poisons size matters. The same dose can be 100 times more harmful in a child than an adult. Mercury is now a part of our environment. Common products such as tuna fish, as well as other fish, and many vaccines other than the MMR vaccine contain mercury. Mercury is also a byproduct of industry. The question is how much mercury can the body tolerate without damage. We have some guidance, such as eating fish no more than 2-3 times per week. But supposed you eat fish 2-3 times per week and also live in an area contaminated with mercury because of industrial pollution? The EPA estimates that 1 woman in 5 during their childbearing years have mercury levels in their blood that exceed EPA safety guidelines. Perhaps we should be worrying more about mercury levels in the environment and not just confine our worries to vaccines.

For more information read the article by Lidia Wasowicz http://tinyurl.com/y4k46t

Clinic Notes: Blaming Moms Blaming Dads for Autism

In the 1940's, after Leo Kanner had described autism in children, psychoanalyst Bruno Bettelheim wrote extensively about the causal relationship between emotionally distant mothers (refrigerator mothers) and their autistic children. Of course, you can imagine the guilt this caused moms. Now maybe it's dad's turn. A recent study by epidemiologist Avi Reichenberg of the Mt. Sinai School of Medicine found that dads older than forty were six times more likely to have children diagnosed with autism than younger dads. Theoretically, the DNA in the older sperm has decayed.

(See James Ottar Grundvig for The Epoch Times at
http://www.theepochtimes.com/news/6-11-13/48039.html)